Your CAC is climbing 75%
Your organic traffic is flat.
The SEO playbook that you ran for a decade+ is obsolete.
Last week, the brutal New Orleans heat took out my AC.
Ten years ago, I would've Googled "AC repair reviews," clicked through five sites, maybe called a friend.
Not this time.
I snapped a photo. Dropped it into Perplexity. In seconds: diagnosis complete, companies vetted, appointment booked. No search rabbit hole. No decision paralysis.
The internet's front door has moved.
It's not a search bar anymore. It's a chat box.
And if you're not inside that conversation, you're invisible.
In this article, I’m going to break down:
Why the rules of online visibility have changed forever
The new playbook for dominating AI-driven search and conversations
Practical strategies to make your brand unmissable in the age of AEO
Let’s go big.
The Brutal Math Behind Your Disappearing Traffic
The Numbers Don't Lie:
60% of organic searches now end without a click
B2B and B2C customer acquisition costs jumped 60-75%
AI platforms command 1.2 billion active users and growing
ChatGPT: 800mm WAU;
Gemini: 400mm MAU;
Claude 19mm MAU;
Perplexity 22mm MAU
This isn't about losing traffic. It's about traffic flowing through new channels.
The money isn't gone. It's just behind a different door.
And the bouncers are ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini.
The Simplest Way To Create and Launch AI Agents
Imagine if ChatGPT and Zapier had a baby. That's Lindy. Build AI agents in minutes to automate workflows, save time, and grow your business.
Let Lindy's agents handle customer support, data entry, lead enrichment, appointment scheduling, and more while you focus on what matters most - growing your business.
Discovery Meets Intelligence
A Tale of Two Futures:
First, the downside: According to Pew Research, when AI overviews appear in search, user clicks drop by half, falling to just 8% from an average of 15%. That’s the nightmare scenario for most operators.
But here’s the upside: land a citation, and your traffic can surge by 2,300% (just ask Matt Diggity). Top sources in AI overviews see a 219% boost in clicks; we’ve watched our own SEO clients ride this wave with smart EEAT and schema implementation (more on that below).
Why Is SEO Still Matters: Dan Petrovic’s GPT-5 Bombshell
GPT-5 isn’t a giant encyclopedia, it’s a reasoning engine. Dan Petrovic (a brilliant ML researcher in SEO) ran real-world tests to prove this point.
OpenAI deliberately made GPT-5 incomplete on purpose. Instead of recalling facts, it “reads the room,” fetching live data from search and external tools. No SEO? Then your brand simply disappears from AI’s train of thought.
“OpenAI made an executive decision to focus on raw intelligence and leave the rest to search engines… Without grounding, this model is virtually useless. It’s designed to be the brain on top of tools and information it’s provided with. This means SEO has never been more relevant than now.”
1. Brand Mentions Are the New Backlinks
Ahrefs data is clear: Web mentions are now the top signal for AI visibility (correlation: 0.664). That dominates legacy SEO metrics
Domain Rating: 0.326
Referring Domains: 0.295
Backlinks: 0.218
Bottom line: AI models trust what the internet says about you, not just who links to you. They’re stitching together reputations from conversations, articles, and lists. Your move: be the main character in those conversations.
Recent studies confirm it: brand mentions in credible sources now drive more SEO upside (via entity recognition) than traditional backlinks, especially in AI-driven search.
Dan Petrovic takes this to the next level. He frames AI visibility as not just luck, but something you can design for:
His Tree Walker algorithm uses bi-directional probing—brand→entity, entity→brand—to map and influence how models connect brands.
Tools like airank.dejan.ai track over 1.2 million entities across GPT, Gemini, and Perplexity, offering competitive intel on how these models associate brands with answers.
2. Reddit Is Your New Homepage
This is the contrarian play 99% of brands are missing. AI engines are obsessed with Reddit. And so am I.
Quick backdrop: I’ve been on Reddit for 20 years. In the late 2000s, Reddit was my not-so-secret weapon for scaling Chunnel.TV to over 500k MAU. That community flywheel? It’s still what powers search today. (Bonus: this year, I finally got to meet Alexis Ohanian. Huge honor. Guy’s a legend, and he gets the platform’s power firsthand).
The Data:
A Profound analysis of 30 million AI citations found:
Perplexity AI pulls 46.7% of citations from Reddit.
Google AI Overviews grabs 21% from Reddit.
ChatGPT saw citations from Reddit jump 436% post content-licensing
New for 2025: Reddit now drives 40.1% of citations in major LLMs, outpacing even Wikipedia (26.3%) and Google (23.4%). Reddit is the dominant training and answer source for AI.
Why Reddit Wins
AI engines crave the real, the unfiltered, the raw: honest user experience, debates, opinions. Reddit is that firehose, no PR filter, just real people talking.
Your Play:
Use AI to help craft valuable, transparent replies on Reddit threads related to your niche or keywords.
Subtly work your brand into authentic discussion (not forced promos, you will get eaten alive).
This isn’t theory: I’ve watched brands crush it in SERPs and show up in LLM citations using this approach. It’s modern reputation engineering.
3. “Best Of” Lists Are Your Golden Ticket
First Page Sage’s data is brutal: authoritative “best of” lists now carry the most weight in AI rankings.
Impact scores:
Perplexity: 64%
Gemini: 49%
ChatGPT: 41%
Translation? One legit “Top 10” mention is worth more than a hundred junk backlinks. AI engines treat high-authority lists as gospel (instant trust).
Stop groveling for guest posts. Rethink outreach: get your brand on those respected lists. That single move will do more for your AI visibility than months of backlink chasing.
Why? When people ask for recommendations, AI pulls answers from Reddit, Quora, YouTube, and especially these “best of” roundups (not from generic blogs). If your brand is seeded in them, you get surfaced in LLM outputs whenever buying decisions happen.
Your move:
Map out the top “must-read” lists in your space.
Target the authors, editors, and mods behind them, add real value, build relationships, and steer your brand into the mix.
Track your inclusion and impact for a repeatable, compounding edge.
Bottom line: Real AI-first visibility? Get cited in the lists everyone trusts.
Platform-Specific Battle Plans
Every AI is a different beast. A one-size-fits-all strategy is a fast-track to invisibility. Here’s how to win on each platform.
Conquering ChatGPT: The Encyclopedia Strategy
The Core Rule:
ChatGPT is citation-hungry and leans hard on repetition and encyclopedic sources. Nearly 47.9% of its attributions come from Wikipedia.
Key Ranking Factors:
Authoritative “Best Of” list mentions (41% impact weight)
High volume of brand mentions across trusted spaces
Long-form reviews from reputable sites
Action Plan:
Get on ‘Best Of’ Lists:
Make it a quarterly KPI. Secure mentions in at least 5 credible listicles every quarter. These move the needle for both AI and human visibility.Optimize for Multi-Engine LIVE Search:
Yes, ChatGPT uses Bing for live search, so submit your site and sitemap to Bing Webmaster Tools.
But here’s the move: SEOs now report (and The Information confirms) that ChatGPT and others are also using SERPAPI to pull fresh, blended results from Google, Bing, and more. Winning means: audit how your brand appears across multiple engines and SERP features.
Track your knowledge panel, rich snippets, and FAQ visibility. Micro-wins across platforms boost your odds with LLMs.
Build a Durable Wikipedia Presence:
Seed comprehensive, well-cited content about your brand on third-party sites that Wikipedia editors trust and link out to. This drives citations not just on Wikipedia, but also in AI surfacing.Use Structured Q&A & Parseable Content:
ChatGPT remixes snappy, quotable answers. Engineer your on-site content with structured Q&A blocks and concise explanations. Think “easy to pull, easy to cite.”
With GPT-5’s grounding design, every answer must be verifiable, your content has to make sourcing effortless.
ChatGPT is “lazy” with citations. It defaults to what’s reliable and easy-to-reference. Make your brand the path of least resistance for accurate, attributable info.
Mastering Perplexity: The Speed Demon
The Core Rule:
Perplexity rewards fresh, authoritative content, fast. Speed to publish and nailing high-value topics win the game.
Top Ranking Factors:
High click-through rate (CTR) in the first 24–48 hours (early velocity is everything)
Topic multipliers: AI, tech, business, and trending searches get disproportionate visibility
Operator Action Plan:
Engineer Launch Velocity:
Treat every new post like a product drop. Push hard on promotion right out of the gate (social, email, PR, syndication) to drive immediate clicks and engagement. The algorithm notices your first 48 hours.Target High-Multiplier Topics:
Prioritize what Perplexity boosts: AI, technology, business. Timing and topic selection act as force multipliers for reach.Sync With YouTube:
Align new Perplexity-targeted articles with fresh YouTube videos. Use exact-match titles between the two platforms. This lets you dominate answer boxes and vertical search, a synergy Perplexity favors in responses.Leverage Real-Time Video Content:
Perplexity is tuned for up-to-the-minute, verifiable sources (especially video transcripts). Always transcribe your YouTube content; optimize for key topics and clarity to increase citation odds.
Perplexity outruns ChatGPT and Gemini on recency and fact-checking, especially in fast-moving topics. Think “live news desk,” not encyclopedia. You can’t fake freshness so build your workflow for speed and authority.
Dominating Gemini: The Authority Machine
The Core Rule:
Gemini is laser-wired into Google’s Knowledge Graph, Shopping Graph, and user data. If you want authority, you need structure and demonstrable trust.
Top Ranking Factors:
Maximum E-E-A-T: Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness are non-negotiable.
Comprehensive, well-implemented Schema markup (JSON-LD).
Operator Action Plan:
Full-Throttle Schema Deployment:
Don’t half-step. Embed detailed JSON-LD schema (Article, FAQPage, HowTo, Organization, Person) on every priority page. The goal: make every asset instantly machine-readable for LLMs and Google’s indexers.Own AI Overviews (AIOs):
AIOs surface for nearly all informational keywords (99.2%), especially long-tail (73.6% for queries >5 words). Structure your content for direct answers, think summaries, Q&As, step-by-steps, highlights right up front. Design for snippetability.Signal E-E-A-T Everywhere:
Highlight credentials, unique research, real-world experience, and consistent third-party citations. Be the single source Gemini wants to trust (across content and social proof).Advanced: Power Tools for Pro Operators
Provide Gemini examples: Feed it 100+ top-tier samples (text, image, audio) to dial in brand context (it’s now fully multimodal, including function calling).
Leverage DSPy for custom prompt optimization on complex workflows.
Take advantage of Gemini’s new URL Context Tool: Make sure key site/pages are crawlable, always fresh, and rich in structured data. Gemini will now fetch up to 20 URLs live per request, including PDFs and JSON for inline citation and context-building.
Schema for Gemini is direct model guidance. You’re shaping its output boundaries and reducing fluff while upgrading citation accuracy. Operator overkill? Maybe. But in 2025, it’s the difference between “findable” and “forgotten.”
The Anti-Playbook: Stop Wasting Money On This… Immediately
Stop pouring budget into these dead-end tactics:
Domain Authority fixation:
The impact just isn’t there. Domain Authority has a weak 0.326 correlation with AI citations, while actual brand mentions clock in at 0.664. In the world of AEO, DA is more of a vanity stat.Chasing backlink volume:
AI cares about mentions in meaningful context, not your raw link count. Ahrefs shows the total number of backlinks correlates at just 0.218 with AI visibility. Real conversations and reputable mentions matter more.Social signal gaming:
AI doesn’t care about how many likes or shares you rack up. Instead, engines are scraping genuine user discussions (think Reddit threads, YouTube comments, real conversation) for signals about authority and brand relevance.
Dan Petrovic calls out the hype around “Generative Engine Optimization” as mostly noise. He argues that SEO already owns the AI channel, thanks to evolved workflows like mechanistic interpretability (breaking down how models perceive brands) and steering (actively shaping those perceptions).
The point is: don’t rename the industry, adapt its methods. Remember, LLMs themselves don’t natively understand schema, it’s the tools and APIs surrounding them that bring that structure into play.
From Hack to Brand
Here's the uncomfortable truth:
SEO is no longer a tactic to be hacked.
Yes, you absolutely need technical specialists who understand schema markup and content optimization. Yes, you need experts who decode LLM ranking factors and AI engine preferences.
But there’s more at stake.
AEO demands something SEO never required: You have to become worthy of citation.
AI engines evaluate your reputation. They synthesize conversations about your brand across Reddit, YouTube, forums, and social platforms. They judge whether you deserve to be the answer.
This is the brand element: Your reputation precedes your ranking.
This is the community element: People have to actually talk about you, organically, authentically.
This is the reputation element: You can't fake your way into AI citations the way you could game PageRank.
The brands winning in AEO aren't just technically optimized, they're genuinely worth mentioning. They participate in communities. They earn respect through expertise (and distribution), not ranking manipulation.
You can't hack trust. You can't shortcut authority. You can't fake authentic community engagement.
If this newsletter lit a fire under you, forward it to one person who would benefit.
🎁 Get rewarded for sharing! My team grew NEW accounts to over 50 million views in just a few months. We made an AI viral hook generator so you can follow the same hook frameworks that we do.
Invite your friends to join, and when they sign up, you’ll unlock our AI Viral Hook Generator—the ultimate tool for creating scroll-stopping content.
{{rp_personalized_text}}
Copy and paste this link: {{rp_refer_url}}